Toby wrote:
Quote:
On Sun, 08 Oct 2006 22:22:34 -0700, Nicholas Andrade <sdnick484@nospam.yahoo.com> wrote:
Quote:
SteveL wrote:
Quote:
|
Thanks for replies. The iPod solution looks like a winner.
|
Rather than locking yourself to an iPod, have you considered BMW's official Aux Audio Input connector: http://www.my330i.com/mod26.php The piece is only $40, and it will take audio from any source. I have an iPod now, but I don't know (and honestly doubt) I will in the next couple years (but I'll most likely have my 330 still). Like the guide above, I mounted it above the shifter and it works great.
|
Sure, if you want low-quality audio,
|
First off, if you're using a stock deck, chances are audio quality isn't
a top priority. Furthermore, the post I'm replying to is suggesting a
solution that will lock the user into an iPod -- a device where unless
the user is only using Apple's Lossless codec will already have lossy
songs. With the auxillary in option, you can use a device which
supports line out and a multitude of lossless codecs (FLAC, MonkeyAudio,
etc.) -- in this case audio quality would actually be better. If the
user already has all their songs in Apple's Lossless format, they might
as well go with the iPod solution as they're pretty much vertically
locked to Apple devices. Personally, I keep most of my songs in both
FLAC and MP3, so in the future when I find a device I like which
supports FLAC, migration will be trivial.
no ID3 tags,
The ID3 tags are on the device; personally at the moment I just leave my
iPod in the cup holder, and I'm fairly confident I'll do the same with
any future device. If you do a lot of night driving, than perhaps this
is an issue; I usually try to pay attention to the road and not scroll
through my music collection when I'm driving at night...
and no ability to control it from the steering wheel controls. It's
perfect then.
While you can't change tracks, you can still control the volume. I
guess the importance of being able to scroll through your music depends
on how you go about listening to it. About 85% of the time I use either
a "My Top Rated" or "Songs Not Played Recently", and the remaining 15%
of the time I just listen to a single artist/album. In both cases,
scrolling through isn't a major issue since I can just press the next
track on the device.
Basically what it comes down to is if you foresee yourself staying with
an iPod for as long as you have your car or you buy all your music
through iTunes and are locked in, than you should probably go with an
iPod solution. If you believe that before you sell your car you'll be
switching audio players (at the moment I expect to, my iPod is a 3rd
generation, and I definitely don't see enough value added in Apple's
current offerings), then going with a generic audio in is probably the
better choice.